Welcome to The Pizza Heist
Welcome to The Pizza Heist, a beloved gem nestled at 231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY. Renowned for its mouthwatering pizzas and wings, this spot has captured the hearts of locals and visitors alike. With a brilliant build-your-own pizza option and an array of tempting appetizers, including crispy onion rings and hearty chicken wings, there's something for everyone. Customers rave about the affordable prices and generous portions, highlighting fresh ingredients and flavorful recipes. The dedicated staff ensures a cheerful atmosphere that makes every visit feel special. Join the loyal fanbase and indulge in a culinary heist you won't forget!
-
231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY 14086, United States231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY 14086, United States Hotline: +1 716-681-1111
Welcome to The Pizza Heist, a hidden gem located at 231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY. This delightful eatery has garnered enthusiastic praise for its delectable pizzas and mouthwatering wings. With a motto that resonates with both locals and visitors alike, The Pizza Heist transforms the act of dining into an unforgettable experience, enticing food lovers from far and wide.
The menu features an impressive array of specials that cater to all cravings. For just $70.99, you can indulge in two large special pizzas alongside 50 boneless wings. Or perhaps you fancy a more intimate dinner? The large pizza paired with 30 wings at $50.99 could be the perfect choice. Even solo diners can savor delectable options like the Chicken Finger Special, which includes three fingers, fries, and refreshing beverages for only $13.99.
Cusotmer feedback shines a spotlight on the consistent quality and welcoming atmosphere at The Pizza Heist. One delighted patron, Kelly White, extols it as "the best place on earth for pizza and wings," highlighting not just the flavor but also affordability. Another loyal customer, BuffaloBills4L, lauds it as "the greatest pizza & wings in all of Buffalo," emphasizing that the quality only seems to improve with each visit.
Beyond pizza and wings, their chicken fingers also get rave reviews. Joella Laramay recently enjoyed a chicken finger salad, which she found perfectly portioned with fresh ingredients. The mozzarella sticks, while a bit crispy for her taste, were undeniably fresh, proving that The Pizza Heist is committed to quality from start to finish.
The ambiance of the restaurant adds to the experience. Diners are greeted with smiling employees who contribute to a friendly atmosphere. As customer Jacobi Pizza notes, despite the competition in Lancaster, The Pizza Heist stands out as one of the best options available. The staff's attentiveness is evident, ensuring orders are taken smoothly, even for those who might be indecisive, as Joseph Andrews can attest.
In essence, The Pizza Heist does more than serve delicious food; it creates a community. With mouthwatering dishes and superb customer service, it's no wonder that this eatery garners such loyal patrons. So, whether you're a local or just passing through, be sure to make a stop and discover why The Pizza Heist is consistently a favorite in the Buffalo area. You might just find your new go-to spot for pizza and wings!
Best place on earth for pizza and wings. Along with their other menu items. Prices are less than the other pizzerias around.
Seriously the greatest pizza & wings in all of Buffalo. I’ve been ordering from here for the past 4 years and it gets better every time. I love you pizza heist!!
I feel like I got a steal, pun intended, a small chicken finger salad and mozzy sticks for 11 bucks! The salad was delicious, perfectly portioned, had plenty of chicken in it with fresh lettuce, tomato slices and cheese. The mozzy sticks were a little too crispy but were definitely fresh. I'm definitely coming back!
Employees always seem happy, food is always great. So many pizzerias in a small radius in Lancaster, this is def the top 1 or 2
After seeing a pizza review online I thought I’d give it a run. Pizza had a nice soft dough, crispy crust and a slightly sweet sauce. Employee at counter was very good at taking my order when I wasn’t sure what I wanted. Haha. I did notice that they get a lot of people that come in for the 2 slice special. That tells me this is a consistently good food spot. I will go again.
Stopped in for the Monday large 1 topping deal and got a Large cheese with banana peppers and onion for about 16. Very good pizza with generous topping portions. The toppings were very fresh and the crust had a delicious oven taste. They appear to use cheese slices, which I like and the sauce is very light and subtle. This is a great deal!
Their cheese and pepperoni pizza is one of my favorites! They sauce is slightly sweet and they do not skimp on it. Many of my usual pizzerias seem to be cutting corners and putting fewer ingredients than normal, but The Pizza Heist has stayed consistent for many years. They are also amazing community members, contributing to local fundraisers. I would highly recommend checking them out if you haven't already!
The old man ordered lg pizza and wings last night. Delicious pizza was thick with cheese saucy just like I like it the pepperoni was perfectly sliced. I love a pizza like this. Old school to discribe like it’s supposed to be. Even the dough was delish dipped it in the blue cheese. Mmmmhm then the wings were perfect as well crispy medium. I hate a sloppy wing I wonder if they are fully cooked. These wings they took their time frying it was crispy like I like it. Perfect dinner and yes I enjoyed it for lunch as well the next day Thany you Pizza Hiest