The Pizza Heist Menu (2025 Update)
Welcome to The Pizza Heist, a culinary gem located at 231 Aurora St, Lancaster, NY. This vibrant pizzeria specializes in mouth-watering pizzas and succulent chicken wings, making it a top choice for locals and visitors alike. The menu features customizable options with a Build Your Own Pizza section, offering sizes ranging from small to sheet, ensuring every craving is satisfied. Specialty pizzas like the Chicken Finger and Taco Pizza showcase unique flavors, each priced around $15.99.
Alongside delicious pizzas, the 30-piece chicken wings are a standout, starting at just $13.99. Customers rave about the quality and affordability, with reviews praising the soft dough and crispy crust. The warm, friendly atmosphere and happy staff add to the experience, making you feel welcomed every time you visit. With its exceptional dishes and generous portions, The Pizza Heist is truly a must-try for anyone seeking the best pizza and wings in the area!
APPETIZERS Please Select Size For Correct Pricing
Mozzarella Sticks
Onion Rings
Mac & Cheese Bites
French Fries
Bread Sticks
Garlic Bread
Sampler Platter
(2) Chicken fingers, (2) Mozzarella sticks, (4) Poppers, (2) Pizza Logs, & (1) order of onion rings.
Hot Poppers
Fried Dough
Pizza Logs
Tator Tots
Apple Pie Logs
Chef Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, black olives, and cheddar.
Antipasto Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, ham, salami, capicola, pepperoni, mozzarella, black olives and green olives.
Grilled Chicken Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, chicken, mozzarella.
Chicken Finger Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, chicken, mozzarella, and cheddar.
Tuna Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, tuna, and mozzarella.
Taco Salad
Julienne Salad
Lettuce, tomatoes, croutons, turkey, ham, mozzarella, and cheddar.
SALADS Please Select Size For Correct Pricing
TACOS Please Select Size For Correct Pricing
Beef & Cheese
Chicken Finger
Veggie
Steak
Chicken Finger Special
3 Fingers & Fries with Blue Cheese, Celery & Carrot Sticks & 20 oz. Soda.
Small Pizza for Two Special 10 Boneless Wings
Small Cheese 1 Item Pizza & 10 Boneless Wings
Small Pizza for Two Special 10 Regular Wings
Small Cheese 1 Item Pizza & 10 Wings.
Small Pizza for Two Special 5 Chicken Fingers
Small Cheese 1 Item Pizza & 5 Chicken Fingers
Two Large Pizza Special
2 Large Pizzas Cheese 1 Item
Large Pizza and Chicken Wings
Large pizza and 20 wings
Large Pizza and Boneless Wings
Large pizza and 20 boneless wings.
Large Pizza and Chicken Fingers
Large pizza & 10 chicken fingers
Large Pizza & 30 Wings Special
Large pizza and 30 wings
Large Pizza & 30 Boneless Wings Special
Large pizza and 30 boneless wings
Sheet Pizza & 30 Wings Special
with Cheese 1 Item
Sheet Pizza & 30 Boneless Wings
with Cheese 1 Item
1 Sheet Pizza & 50 Wings Special
With Cheese 1 Item Pizza & 50 regular wings.
1 Sheet Pizza & 50 Boneless Wings Special
With Cheese 1 Item Pizza & 50 boneless wings.
1 Sheet Pizza & 25 Chicken Fingers
With Cheese 1 Item Pizza & 25 chicken fingers.
2 Large Special & 50 Wings
With Cheese 1 Item Pizza & 50 regular wings.
2 Large Special & 50 Boneless Wings
With Cheese 1 Item Pizza & 50 boneless wings.
2 Large Special & 25 Chicken Fingers
With Cheese 1 Item Pizza & 25 chicken fingers.
PIZZA & WING SPECIALS
PIZZA
Build Your Own Pizza (Sheet)
Build Your Own Pizza (Large)
Build Your Own Pizza (Small)
White Pizza
Brushed with house oil, covered with fresh tomatoes, onions, blended cheeses, and sprinkled with seasonings
Veggie Pizza
Mushrooms, onions, choice of peppers, choice of olives, and cheese.
Taco Pizza
Choice of taco, steak or chicken, topped with fresh lettuce, black olives, and tomato.
Garlic Bread Pizza
Topped with cheese, garlic bits and seasoning.
Chicken Finger Pizza
Your choice of Hot/Med/Mild or BBQ sauces, covered with mozzarella cheese and chopped chicken fingers. Served with bleu cheese on the side.
Steak Pizza
Brushed with oil, mozzarella cheese, choice of peppers, onions, and chopped steak.
SPECIALTY PIZZAS Please Select Size For Correct Pricing
CHICKEN FINGERS
5 Pieces
10 Pieces
15 Pieces
25 Pieces
10 Piece
20 Piece
30 Piece
50 Piece
CHICKEN WINGS
BONELESS WINGS
10 Piece
20 Piece
30 Piece
50 Piece
Ham
Cold
Turkey
Cold
Ham & Turkey
Cold
Salami
Cold
Cheese Sub
Cold
Tuna
Cold
Capicola
Cold
Assorted
Cold
Turkey Club
Cold
Pizza
Hot
Sausage
Hot
Steak
Hot
Chicken Fingers
Hot
Chicken Fingers Pizza Sub
Hot
Grilled Chicken
Hot
BLT
Hot
Royal
Hot
Cheeseburger
Hot
Bacon Cheeseburger
Hot
Stinger
Hot
Hoagie
SUBS & WRAPS Please Select Size For Correct Pricing
DRINKS
Bottled Drink (20 Oz.)
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Cherry Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, Ginger Ale, Root Beer, Water, Red Gatorade , Purple Gatorade, Yellow Gatorade, Peach Tea, Lemon Tea, Diet Green Tea, or Diet Dr. Pepper.
2 Liter Soda
Pepsi, Diet Pepsi, Cherry Pepsi, Sierra Mist, Dr. Pepper, Mountain Dew, or Ginger Ale.